One reason I only allow one exception to when I’ll release IP information is that trolls tend to use multiple identities and so when there is an especially egregious case such as the clown who linked to a amputee dancing and called it the Duckwalk, I can publicly shame the individual.
If you use one pseudonym generally (you can change it–just don’t do it midthread or many times in the same day) or post anonymously, I protect your privacy absent a court order/warrent. And as long as you aren’t lying about who you are such as John Lott and Mary Rosh or a campaign pretending to be another campaign, I don’t care. So don’t feel nervous about what I’m about to do if you follow those very simple guidelines.
Let’s review IPs and Identities on ArchPundit revoling around an ID that also had an IP address the same as the person who posted the offensive link to the video
http://www.archpundit.com/archives/013331.html
Post: Since March 2nd
2006-03-08 16:20:01
IP Address of commentor: 66.73.162.11
Name: TrueDemocrat
E-mail: ilyayavitz@lycos.com
Published: 2006-03-10 06:43:56
Also from the same IP address in that post is an anonymous comment.
2006-03-09 04:34:29
66.73.162.11
http://www.archpundit.com/archives/013341.html
Pre-Primary: Cegelis D-IL-06
2006-03-10 10:36:39
66.73.162.11
TrueDemocratReal
2006-03-10 11:21:40
http://www.archpundit.com/archives/013343.html
Pre-Primary: Duckworth D-IL-06
2006-03-10 11:29:44
66.73.162.11
RealDemocratAuthentic
2006-03-10 16:25:05
2006-03-11 00:02:55
http://www.archpundit.com/archives/013476.html
It was a Mistake, but I’m Pretty Sure an Honest One
2006-03-24 15:12:41
66.73.160.70
TrueDemocratRealAuthentic
2006-03-25 02:41:52
2006-03-26 13:59:44
The list could go on if I listed the other identities connected to ilyayavitz@lycos.com or ilyayavitz@uchicago.edu or metonym@uchicago.edu under the different names of Formalist, ilyayavitz, Illinois06 and variations of TrueDemocratRealAuthentic and all of them are from a small subset of IP addresses (a total of 4) registered to SBC Chicago. In some cases, one comment would be posted under one name and the next comment would be from the same IP under a different name.
And then finally, the comment with the link to the video came from 66.73.160.70
The clowns name is and he is an
He’s used these multiple identities at other sites including MyDD and apparently was banned from there under a couple different identities. He’s also used them at Kos.
He’s a troll, a liar, and a scumbag and if I detect him again posting in comments, those will be deleted. He’s banned from using the site other than viewing it.
Quick Update: And despite his protestations of donating money to many Democratic candidates, he doesn’t show up in the FEC database. Meaning he may donate, but doesn’t break the $200 threshhold for reporting. Other Cegelis volunteers have no memory of him, though he did write a letter tot he editor.