Obama

Info-Pimping

Charles Madigan writes a good defense of the the media in general and while I tend to get particularly annoyed as of late with some of the stories I see coming out (David Broder saying Democrats aren’t sympathetic to the military for example) I think it’s important to praise those who do good work.

Madigan, Zorn, Miller, Sweet, and Chapman strike me as exceptionally good columnists and very good at fact checking. Chambers, Fornek, McDermott, usually Pearson, and Zeleny (now at NY Times) (and I’m sure I’m forgetting some people so don’t whine like bloggers to me) all are very good reporters who get their facts straight and despite caterwauling primarily from the right, are excellent observers of the political scene.

As I’ve said before, I’ve fallen victim/perpetrated info-pimping and try and be as straightforward with readers when I screw up with those incidents.

The problem many liberal activists and bloggers perceive and I think does exist is that over time the right wing has established an echo chamber that is particularly good and working the refs. The answer to it for most of us is to work the refs too. It’s a problematic solution because it adds to the postmodern notion that facts are relative to one’s view of the world. By doing the same thing, the notion that both ‘sides’ are the same is reinforced and we get more he said-he said journamalism that doesn’t try and accurately portray reality–hello global warming skeptics hacks.

But what else is the answer? Today we see a stupid meme from Fran Eaton and the Illinois Review show up in a fairly long story in the Tribune discussing how conservatives are arguing that Trinity is a black supremacist church that has weird beliefs on the middle class.

This despite a document on the church web site I found several weeks ago explaining what is meant by Trinity’s 12 precepts which does explain the statements very clearly. There is a reality underlying the accusations and it’s not friendly to Eaton yet the community paper Eaton writes for published her commentary and the Tribune picked up the story.

All the facts are correct in the story (except that the web site doesn’t have further context), but it still leaves the impression that there is something advocating weird views on the middle class or is even black supremacist. The story about the ‘controversy’ furthers the purpose of the story in the first place to make Obama sound out of the mainstream even though the values under the Black Values System are very mainstream points of view.

The journalistic practice of being fair and finding opposing viewpoints furthers the purpose of those trying to push the story. I don’t know how to fix this problem. I have a lot of respect for many journalists and while I criticize the profession, I’m glad the good reporters are there for the very reasons Madigan cites, but too often we are dealing with freak show stories that shouldn’t even be in the media and the media reports on them because of the ‘controversy.’

Sharpton aims to be the Voice of Reason

It’s really funny:

The controversy triggered by Jones was picked up by CNN Monday, and the Rev. Al Sharpton told CNN that Jones “could offend people by saying you got to unite just because someone is your race.”

Sharpton noted that Obama endorsed Mayor Daley for re-election over two black candidates, so it would not follow to ask blacks “to do something for Obama that he himself is not doing at home.”

Hysterical.

Rich has a good take on it over at Capitol Fax as well.

Rich says it well, and I say this not to criticize Stoller here, but to point out this is why local bloggers are essential to covering stories with local angles. I didn’t even take the bit about patronage politics seriously from Jones because he’s Jones. I like Jones, I just am not naive enough to buy that he wouldn’t make the exact opposite argument if he was in Joe Bruno’s job.

Daily Dolts: Pavlovian Press Corp

Right Wing idiots start a meme about Democratic Politician, mainstream publications put it in print as covering the ‘controversy.’ The problem being the controversy isn’t a controversy, but your drummed up crap to distract:

At the same time, conservative critics already have begun a buzz on the Internet about a far less known part of his biography: his adherence to the creed of the prominent South Side church he attends, Trinity United Church of Christ. The congregation posits what it terms a Black Value System, including calls to be “soldiers for black freedom” and a “disavowal of the pursuit of middleclassness.”

In an interview late Monday, Obama said it was important to understand the document as a whole rather than highlight individual tenets. “Commitment to God, black community, commitment to the black family, the black work ethic, self-discipline and self-respect,” he said. “Those are values that the conservative movement in particular has suggested are necessary for black advancement.

“So I would be puzzled that they would object or quibble with the bulk of a document that basically espouses profoundly conservative values of self-reliance and self-help.”

In his published memoirs, Obama said even he was stopped by Trinity’s tenet to disavow “middleclassness” when he first read it two decades ago in a church pamphlet. The brochure implored upwardly mobile church members not to distance themselves from less fortunate Trinity worshipers.

“As I read it, at least, it was a very simple argument taken directly from Scripture: `To whom much is given much is required,'” Obama said in the interview.

Now, let me point out here that is someone questioned a conservative on their faith in such a context, we’d be hearing caterwauling about attacks on Christians. Middleclassness is simply a belief that those with resources, don’t take that as an excuse to belittle those without resources–iow, it’s a rejection of the notion of the Protestant Work Ethic in the worst sense-where one can judge those who are not successful as not being the chosen.

It’s such a simple point and based in the central core of the the teachings of Jesus. To attack it out of stupidity or maliciousness demonstrates the gulf between the races in this country. That such an attack isn’t taken as political opportunism or simple stupidity, shows the vapidity of our press corps.

But Obama scoffed at the suggestion that Trinity espouses a value system that seeks to help blacks exclusively. “If I say to anybody in Iowa–white, black, Hispanic or Asian–that my church believes in the African-American community strengthening families or adhering to the black work ethic or being committed to self-discipline and self-respect and not forgetting where you came from, I don’t think that’s something anybody would object to.

“I think I’d get a few amens.”

Now the stupidest thing written in the article is:

Trinity, which adopted the principles in 1981, highlights them in brief form on its Web site without elaboration. That leaves room for critics to fill the vacuum.

Really, what is this:

THE BLACK VALUE SYSTEM

Statement of Purpose

We honor Dr. Manford Byrd, our brother in Christ, because of the exemplary manner in
which he has thrice withstood the ravage of being denied his earned ascension to the
number one position in the Chicago School System. His dedication to the pursuit of
excellence despite these systemic denials has inspired the congregation of Trinity United
Church of Christ. We have prayerfully called the wisdom of all past generations of
suffering Blacks for guidance in fashioning an instrument of Black self-determination,
the Black Value System.

And we shall, beginning in 1982, institute an annual Black Value System-Educational
Scholarship in the name of Dr. Byrd.

This year, 1981, however, we recognize Dr. Byrd as the first recipient of the Dr. Manford
Byrd Award which will be given annually to the man or woman who best exemplifies the
Black Value System.

The Black Value System

These Black Ethics must be taught and exampled in homes, churches, nurseries and
schools, wherever Blacks are gathered. They must reflect the following concepts:
Commitment of God

“The God of our weary years” will give us the strength to give up prayerful passivism
and become Black Christian Activist, soldiers for Black freedom and the dignity of all
humankind.

Commitment to the Black Community

The highest level of achievement for any Black person must be a contribution of
substance to the strength and continuity of the Black of the Black Community.
Commitment to the Black Family

The Black family circle must generate strength, stability, and love despite the uncertainty
of externals, because these characteristics are required if the developing person is to
withstand warping by our racist competitive society.

Those Blacks who are blessed with membership in a strong family unit must reach out
and expand that blessing to the less fortunate, especially to the children.

Dedication to the Pursuit of Education

We must forswear anti-intellectualism. Continued survival demands that each Black
Person be developed to the utmost of his/her mental potential despite the inadequacies of
the formal education process. “Real education” fosters understanding of ourselves as
well as every aspect of our environment. Also it develops within us the ability to fashion
concepts and tools for better utilization of our resources, and more effective solutions to
our problems. Since the majority of Blacks have been denied such learning, Black
Education must include elements that provide high school graduates with marketable
skills, a trade or qualifications for apprenticeships, or proper preparation for college.
Basic education for all Blacks should include Mathematics, Science, Logic, General
Semantics, Participative Politics, Economics and Finance, and the Care and Nurture of
Black minds.

To the extent that we individually reach for, even strain for excellence, we increase,
geometrically, the value and resourcefulness of the Black Community. We must
recognize the relativity of one’s best: this year’s best can be bettered next year. Such is
the language of growth and development. We must seek to excel in every endeavor.

Adherence to the Black Work Ethic

“It is becoming harder to find qualified people to work in Chicago” Whether this is true
or not, it represents one of the many reasons given by businesses and industries for
deserting the Chicago area. We must realize that a location with good facilities, adequate
transportation and reputation for producing skilled workers will attract industry. We are
in competition with other cities, states, and nations for jobs. High productivity must be a
goal of the Black workforce.

Commitment to Self-Discipline and Self-Respect

To accomplish anything worthwhile requires self-discipline. We must be a community of
self-disciplined persons, if we are to actualize and utilize our own human resources
instead of perpetually submitting to exploitation by others. Self discipline coupled with a
respect for self, will enable each of us to be an instrument of Black Progress, and a model
for Black Youth.

Disavowal of the Pursuit of “Middleclassness”

Classic methodology on control of captives teaches that captors must keep the captive
ignorant educationally, but trained sufficiently well to serve the system. Also, the captors
must be able to identify the “talented tenth” of those subjugated, especially those who
show promise of providing the kind of leadership that might threaten the captor’s control.
Those so identified as separated from the rest of the people by:
Killing them off directly, and/or fostering a social system that encourages them to kill off
one another.

Placing them in concentration camps, and/or structuring an economic environment that
induces captive youth to fill the jails and prisons.

Seducing them into a socioeconomic class system which while training them to earn
more dollars, hypnotizes them into believing they are better than others and teaches them
to think in terms of “we” and “they” instead of “us”.

So, while it is permissible to chase “middle-incomeness” with all our might, we must
avoid the third separation method-the psychological entrapment of Black
“middleclassness”: If we avoid the snare, we will also diminish our “voluntary”
contributions to methods A and B. And more importantly, Black people no longer will
be deprived of their birthright, the leadership, resourcefulness, and example of their own
talented persons.

Pledge to Make the Fruits of All Developing and Acquired Skills
Available to the Black community

Pledge to Allocate Regularly, a Portion of Personal Resources for Strengthening and
Supporting Black Institutions.

Pledge Allegiance to all Black Leadership Who Espouse and Embrace The Black Value
System.

Personal Commitment to Embracement of the Black Value System – to Measure the
Worth and Validity of All Activity in Terms of Positive Contributions to the General
Welfare of the Black Community and the Advancement of Black People towards
Freedom.

If you are a Christian, I’d love to know what is controversial about any of the above.

Ain’t it a bitch to be a black man in the land of the free and the home of the brave

OK, I had another motherboard blow last week so I’m a bit behind. First up, is Chris Hayes’ article on Axelrod and Obama which I think was meant to be a critical look, but is fawning–but not in a bad way. In the way that as much as you want to be cynical about political operatives, Axelrod is really good at overcoming that cynicism. He’s a true believer. A strategic true believer, but a true believer.

It’s very good so go check it out at the Nation
.

You have to read the article to get the quote–and it’s worth it too.

Update: Fixed Chris Hayes’ name which I butchered two different ways in a relatively short name. I wish I could claim to be dyslexic, but I’m not. I’ll be calling Daniel Biss Daniel Bliss again soon too I’m sure.

Frank James Nails It

I probably mention the Swamp too seldom because they do exactly what I think a good newspaper blog by reporters can do very well by providing quick updates and covering small stories that won’t make the print edition. James makes the point about Biden’s quote:

Note to Biden. Well-spoken black people hate it when white people call them “articulate.” It’s the modern-day version of what white people used to say back in the day when they thought that by saying “He’s a credit to his race” they were saying something that a black person would welcome hearing.

Those dated words, like Biden’s comments, were patronizing at the very least. And they also appeared to carry some pretty negative assumptions about the majority of the race.

In fact, Biden could’ve pared his thoughts down and just called Obama a credit to his race. It would have had pretty much the same effect.

It’s the same as when Syverson and Rauschenberger thought they should find an articulate black man to oppose Obama in 2004.

Keyes’ Company

How Obama is Like Barbaro

Similarly, those who swoon at the sight of Senator Beefcake can find in his ponderous, ambiguous statements about serious issues whatever they want to hear. The shame that was Katrina isn’t about race, except that it is. He is a devout Christian who is proud of his brother’s conversion to Islam. He is black, except when he’s thinking of himself as a “half breed.”

Liberals have a well-known propensity for adopting mascots and purporting to speak for them. If they literally can’t speak for themselves (inanimate objects like trees, animals), all the better. Now they have applied this standard to the man that I call He Who Walks on Water and what at least one commentator has called an empty suit who is no doubt delighted to watch his political fortunes rise without his having to clarify what he really thinks, and his real agenda for this country. Come to think of it, we would be better off with Mr. Ed.

So the first African-American Harvard Law Review is a mascot who can’t speak for himself. A guy who was an Instructor at University of Chicago Law School? It’s legitimate to question his experience on the national and international level. It’s legitimate to want more details from him. However, suggesting he is a token who has to be spoken for is one of the most paternalistic and stupid comments I’ve read even including Joe Biden. This is straight out of the Keyes playbook with the irony being that Keyes’ was the mascot Syverson and Rauschenberger wanted to bring in because he was an articulate black man like Obama.

Are you fucking kidding me with this shit?

But most of all, they put the horse down. How exactly is this a comparison?

Punching Bag Joe

Even when he ‘clarifies’ he leaves hysterical quotes behind:

Joe Biden called Sen. Barack Obama (D-IL) to clarify his “clean” comment to the New York Observer, Biden told reporters in a conference call this afternoon. Biden said Obama told him: “You don’t have to explain anything to me. I know exactly what you meant.”

There is some debate about the appropriate use of commas in the sentence, but that is like arguing over whether Biden’s a Huge Idiot or a Really Huge Idiot. You can’t separate with a comma the comparison made between African-Americans in general and Obama specifically. It’s not about whether he’s the first mainstream black candidate-that’s debateable and is akin to how many angels are on that pin over there–it’s the language that is supposedly contrasting to all candidates, but uniquely chosen examples of stereotypes of black candidates.

Is Biden a huge racist? Probably not, but he’s a goof with verbal diarrhea and an uncanny ability to be completely tone deaf. I point out the point he makes above that reads like a Petey Labarbera line thinking something is making him look better, but makes any person paying attention laugh hysterically. Obama probably was being gracious, but it doesn’t matter when you put it that way.

Finally, nice roll out day–calling a colleague and competitor and taking press questions on that all day.

What’s the Problem?

He was complimenting Obama after all

Yes, Obama is different from all those other African-Americans is, in some sense, a compliment. However, in any other sense, Joe just insulted millions of Americans.

I’m sure Joe thinks people are just being overly sensitive…like all those Indians working in convenience stores instead of being stuck in the ghetto of high tech jobs.

Not merely scientists….