2007

Just What is Fran Trying to Say?

She suggests there’s a rift between Dan Rutherford and the Romney campaign because Romney supports a Constitutional Amendment to ban same sex marriage.  The funny thing is that Dan knew that when he signed up, so why would there be a rift?

Or is it just another instance of baiting Rutherford on issues that don’t matter to voters?

It strikes me that give Illinois Review another year or two and everyone who writes for them will be so alienated from the Republican Party it’ll be like visiting a Green Party blog.

It’s a Terri Schiavo Reunion in Aurora

Friar Frank Pavone from the Terri Schiavo shows up making sure the Circus gets bigger.

And the Thomas More Society is providing legal assistance to the Pro-Life Action Network for them to sue Steve Twombley, Chicago head of Planned Parenthood.

If you look at the letter to aldermen, Trombley included those in Aurora who oppose the clinic in his general smear. Whatever these people are, they are one removed from Scheidler and the League. And the answer on whether Scheidler and the League are violent was answered by the Supreme Court 8-1 and 8-0. Trombley took even that false assertion a step further.

This is his public argument, but I’ll assume he wont’ make that argument in court because it’s really silly. The argument Twombley made is:

The activists of the Pro-Life Action League who have been opposing our new facility are headquartered in Aurora and have a well-documented history of advocating violence against both persons and property as well as other related criminal activity.We think you will understand the urgency of our concerns when you consider the following facts about the Pro-Life Action League and its leader, Joe Scheidler.

Scheidler (along with a handful of other anti-abortion leaders) formed PLAN – the Pro-LIfe Action League. Scheidler called PLAN the “pro-life mafia” and proclaimed “a year of pain and fear” for anyone seeking or providing abortion.

After a six-week trial in 1998, a jury in Chicago unanimously found that the Pro-Life Action League Network orchestrated 121 crimes involving acts of threats of force or violence against women’s health facilities that offered abortion. These crimes proven at trial included beating a post-operative ovarian surgery patient over the head with a sign, knocking her unconscious and causing her to bleed from the sutures in her abdomen; seizing a clinic administrator by the throat, choking and bruising her; and slamming a clinic staff member and volunteer against the stairs (sending them to a hospital and causing permanent injuries) and destroying medications and equipment. Joe Scheidler personally praised the individuals who carried out some of these misdeeds, even taking credit for them….

Claiming that is libelous is silly. The court throwing out the conviction doesn’t say they weren’t tied to the violence, it says the law didn’t cover non-commercial action. The Court made a reasonable reading of the law, but it hardly leads one to conclude that there isn’t a strange coincidence of Joe Scheidler showing up and violence following.

30 by 30 For Mark Pera

Markos joins in on the fun

The ad is up in the corner and you can go here to donate.  Please do.  This is a winnable race with a reactionary, anti-democratic pol born on 3rd base thinking he hit a triple running against a strong progressive candidates who went to work in the steel mill.

Y’know all those races where you vote for the lessor of evils, this isn’t one of them. Mark’s a great guy-honest, humble, and a true progressive.  Help him out.

The End of a Thankless Job

 I’ve often felt sympathy for many of the Governor’s staffers who have good ideas, but have to operate in a pretty toxic environment:

BECKY CARROLL, who often explains budget issues from the perspective of Gov. ROD BLAGOJEVICH, is leaving the administration to work for the presidential campaign of U.S. Sen. BARACK OBAMA, D-Illinois. Carroll, now a deputy governor, will become Obama’s national director of women.

She’ll be a great addition to Obama’s campaign.

Hackneyed Prose Versus Plagiarism

The entire situation regarding Glenn Poshard’s dissertation and thesis is important.There are varying degrees of culpability and certainly Poshard has some there with the question being how serious the violations are.  The examples I’ve seen suggest that he’s not presenting the ideas as his own work and so it does not fall within the worst case scenarios of a plagiarized work, but people who can analyze the material directly and take their time to see the full extent need to make that determination.
However, let me point out that one example is fricken’ silly:

“Drug abuse is not a new phenomenon in America. Various forms of drug abuse have existed for years in the United States and other countries.”

From the U.S. government report:

“Drug abuse is not a new phenomenon. Varying forms of drug abuse have been present for years in the United States and other countries.”

Having discovered several plagiarists from reading papers–some who did it on purpose, other who didn’t understand how to cite and quote material–I would never think to check on either sentence because they are so hackneyed, anyone could have written them and come up with very similar sentence structure.  It’s bad prose in both cases, but not what anyone with a brain would call plagiarism.

Now, if you were planning on plagiarizing either sentence above would be a great way to disguise it since most readers would be falling asleep before the end of the sentence.

Levels of Ignorance

It’s a bit bizarre to see everyone get their knickers in a twist over a guy who has very little actual power:

NEW YORK – Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad questioned the official version of the Sept. 11 attacks and defended the right to cast doubt on the Holocaust in a tense appearance Monday at Columbia University, whose president accused the hard-line leader of behaving like “a petty and cruel dictator.”

Ahmadinejad smiled at first but appeared increasingly agitated, decrying the “insults” and “unfriendly treatment.” Columbia President Lee Bollinger and audience members took him to task over Iran’s human-rights record and foreign policy, as well as Ahmadinejad’s statements denying the Holocaust and calling for the disappearance of Israel.

“Mr. President, you exhibit all the signs of a petty and cruel dictator,” Bollinger said, to loud applause.

The problem with this is that he’s not a dictator.  He has a low level of power in Iran.  The country is primarily run by a small group of clerics who are not elected, unlike Ahmadinejad who barely won election because the reformers split the vote. He’s not terribly powerful, he doesn’t have much influence, and he’s not well liked. But other than that, he’s a real danger.

Iran is far from a dictatorship–it’s an oligarch theocracy run by people who are bad people in general, but not insane.  The guy doesn’t have the authority nor the power to make decisions over Iran’s nuclear program and he doesn’t have the ability to command the armed forces.  He’d end up with a slit throat in bed if he were to try and start a war with Israel.   Not to mention the Sunni countries in the way may not be too happy to have Shiites crossing their territory.

It’s baffling to me that people have gotten into a tizzy over a guy who is largely irrelevant other than making a fool of himself. But there you have the state of American foreign policy discussion today.

GOP Wants to Investigate the Pricing of a Newspaper Ad

I kid you not.

There’s a troubling issue of holding hearings about First Amendment activities.   At best what we have is a mistake by the paper, but most worrisome is the notion that Congress has any business worrying about what the press charges different groups.  It’s not just a private business, but a Constitutionally protected private business, the only class of such businesses receiving such protection.  This is even more ridiculous than the hearings on exit polling that successfully demonstrated that yes, Billy Tauzin is that stupid.
In addition, does anyone care? Other than a bunch of people obsessed with Washington DC and it’s circle of conventional wisdom no one cares.
70 percent of the population wants this war to end within 2 years.   About 60 percent want it in 1 year.  The GOP wants to argue about a newspaper ad.

Are you kidding me?