September 2005

Last (maybe) prediction

No, and not because of some elaborate reason, Edgar wants to spend time with his family and the risk to the legacy throws it over the top.

No inside information, just my guess. And hell, I have a 50% chance of being right. Last time that was true I said Gephardt was the VP nominee so….

Off ot Kansas City for the weekend, but may be able to do some posting–more than anything, I am going to try and catch up on e-mail to many of you.

And remember to subscribe to Illinois Issues which has it’s 30th Anniversary celebration today and is likely to be overshadowed.

Next!

Well, that took a couple hours.

ABC is pointing out that Roy Blunt had employs one of the indictees in the Texas campaign finance scandal . The ROYB (Rely On Your Beliefs) PAC employes Jim Ellis as a consultant and they are happy with his work.

Roy Temple has been all over this of course. Not surprisingly, ROYB had some irregularities as they say.

The case against DeLay is a tough case to make, but the case against Ellis is far more solid. There is one rule in Texas concerning campaign finance–you can’t use corporate or union money to finance election campaigns.

As the Stakeholder points out, no one is even pretending these guys are rogue operatives. In fact, they are ensuring they have ongoing jobs at least until the indictments dropped. Sort of like someone else who is now the former head of FEMA.

Everyone in this case is being “taken care of” and quite well taken care of, yet there has already been a finding in civil court against TRMPAC for violating Texas law and no matter how you add up the math, someone was funneling money to support statewide candidates with corporate donations.

Politics isn’t a way of making people’s lives better for these people, it’s just bidness.

Roy’s Popping An Artery

Roy Temple is a long-time Democratic strategist in Missouri who is known for playing rough. He’s generally a good guy as long as he’s on your side, but he has a special place in his heart for the Blunts. I haven’t added him to the blogroll yet, but that will happen soon for his Fired Up! America site which has state companion sites in Missouri (the MotherShip), Washington and Maryland. He ran the Kerry Campaign in Minnesota in during the general election and won in a close race up there.

He’s all over the Blunt, his relationship with DeLay, TRMPAC and all sorts of other fun Roy and Blunder Boy’s stunts.

Ronnie Earle Yadda, Yadda Yadda

Most people haven’t heard of Ronnie Earle outside of Texas so there’s going to be a rush to label him as on a partisan witchhunt. Oh, wait, that started some time ago.

There is one basic rule in Texas Politics–which is one more than in Illinois–corporations and unions can’t donate directly to political campaigns nor does that allow money to be funneled.

The Washington Post layed out the basic DeLay scheme last year.

From the accompanying article

In May 2001, Enron’s top lobbyists in Washington advised the company chairman that then-House Majority Whip Tom DeLay (R-Tex.) was pressing for a $100,000 contribution to his political action committee, in addition to the $250,000 the company had already pledged to the Republican Party that year.

DeLay requested that the new donation come from “a combination of corporate and personal money from Enron’s executives,” with the understanding that it would be partly spent on “the redistricting effort in Texas,” said the e-mail to Kenneth L. Lay from lobbyists Rick Shapiro and Linda Robertson.

……………

Many corporate donors were explicitly told in TRMPAC letters that their donations were not “disclosable” in public records. But documents from several unrelated investigations offer an exceptional glimpse of how corporate money was able to influence state politics — and also of DeLay’s bold use of his network of corporate supporters to advance his agenda.

Thus, conspiracy to violate the law. Campaign finance cases like this are always tough in terms of nailing the head of the operation because there have to be pretty clear fingerprints if no one flips. In this case, DeLay signed letters for TRMPAC, but he’s still trying to claim nothing was done wrong and that he didn’t know everything sent out. That’s for a jury to sort out, but it’s pretty hard to argue this is a weak case. Already, one civil case based on the same violation of the law was found in favor of the Congressmen who were defeated.

My only complaint with Earle is that he didn’t nail Mattox.

And this is only one of several scandals of which he’s in the middle.

Apparently Dreier was pushed back from being his replacement putting Roy Blunt in some sort of power sharing arrangement. Denny originally named Dreier, but didn’t check with DeLay because he came back announcing Blunt. My guess is that Dreier will be a public face for Blunt who is a poor public speaker and scares small children with his demeanor. He also has some issues with integrity. Roy isn’t so much about turning all of DC into a Republican dominant machine as much as making sure his friends and family plan is well executed.

If it wasn’t clear before, there’s a reason I call Denny, DeLay’s Pool Boy.

DeLay won’t be back either. While he has all sorts of chits to call in, he’ll be toxic by the time this is over. Not only does he face this case, but close associate Jack Abramoff has been indicted bringing along Administration official David Safavian. Adding to the fun is a SEC investigation of Frist which will be pesky, though is the least likely to lead to criminal wrongdoing charges.

A good primer on DeLay’s “issues” is found right here. They haven’t even added Safavian yet.

One might expect that Rove would have to deliver the bad news to The Hammer, but Patrick Fitzgerald’s grand jury in the Plame case is coming to a close next month and Karl might be otherwise occupied.

Even with George Ryan, Ohio and Texas are producing more fun than Illinois right now.

While I think an indictment at a high level in the Blagojevich administration would change the calculus I’m about to make, don’t bet against a Blagojevich administration running against GOP corruption. It seems absurd to many who follow politics closely, but we aren’t the swing voters. With George Ryan fresh in people’s minds, further headlines out of Ohio, and a multitude of scandals in DC he can find a boogeyman to run against and he’s always better with a boogeyman.

My sense is that the overall impact of all of these will be an anti-incumbent mood in 2006 which could swing both ways for Blagojevich–if he can turn it into a referendum on the National GOP and their ideas, he does well, but a skilled candidate can run from the outside and hurt him.

The key to using a strategy for Blagojevich is to use the press’ tendency to report misdeeds on both sides and say any attack is hypocritical. Such a strategy muddies the picture enough to avoid to much taint often. It doesn’t always work as Ernie Fletcher in Kentucky and Bob Taft in Ohio are learning.

I’ll delete any comments about personal lives of the pols above in comments.

Brownie Doesn’t Even Bother With Understanding the Louisiana Evacuation Plan

The essential order of an evacuation is layed out on the map for evacuations

During a threat of a hurricane, a phased evacuation will be based on geographic location and time in which tropical storm winds are forecasted to reach the affected areas.

Phased evacuation procedures are for traffic management purposes only. Consult your local Office of Emergency Preparedness Director for further evacuation information.

Phase I – 50 Hours before onset of tropical storm winds. Includes areas south of the Intracoastal Waterway. These areas are outside any levee protection system and are vulnerable to Category 1 and 2 storms. These areas are depicted in RED on the Evacuation Map. During Phase I there are no route restrictions.

Phase II – 40 Hours before onset of tropical storm winds. Includes areas south of the Mississippi River which are levee protected but remain vulnerable to Category 2 or higher storms. These areas are depicted in on the Evacuation Map. During Phase II there are no route restrictions.

Phase III – 30 Hours before onset of tropical storm winds. Includes areas on the East Bank of the Mississippi River in the New Orleans Metropolitan Area which are within the levee protection system but remain vulnerable to a slow-moving Category 3 or any Category 4 or 5 storm. These areas are depicted in YELLOW on the Evacuation Map. During Phase III, certain routes will be directed and the Contraflow Plan

Brown complains that no one would order the mandatory evacuation, but he misses the importance of these phases from past events like Ivan.

My mistake was in recognizing that for whatever reason that we might want to discuss later, but for whatever reason, Mayor Nagin and Governor Blanco were reticent to order a mandatory evacuation. And if I, Mike Brown individual, could have done something to convince them that this was the big one, and they needed to order a mandatory evacuation,

The thing is that the expected time for landfall was around 10 AM on Monday for most of the planning period. It came in four hours early. Tropical storm winds hit the City of New Orleans around 4 AM from what I’ve seen. Move that to 8 AM as the expected start of tropical storm force winds for the beginning of the process.

50 hours out starts evacuations of areas not protected at what would have been 6 AM on Saturday and we see that many of those areas were ordering those within a couple hours. The storm was only forecast to hit Louisiana with some likelihood in the late afternoon Friday–though not for certain. At 5 PM on Friday, Blanco announced a State of Emergency. So they were late by about 3 hours, but given the time of day, that probably is pretty irrelevant and any earlier had the real potential to be a false alarm

At 40 hours out, which would have been mid-afternoon Saturday places like Placquemines and St. Bernard should have been ordering evacuations. These had to start before Contraflow to avoid disruptions to traffic coming from those areas. Contraflow was begun at 4 PM on Saturday along with a call within that hour for evacuations from New Orleans that were voluntary.

New Orleans and Jefferson were supposed to wait some time before issuing mandatory evacuations because they would stop other traffic from getting out. So they are supposed to wait until 30 hours out. Jefferson essentially made that a bit early, but no one was complaining. Nagin essentially said it was a mandatory evacuation, but he didn’t think he could enforce it (stupid, but still made the point). That gave him until about 2 AM Sunday to make the order according to the timeline. He did the next morning at 9 AM. I think most would say he should have called it early in this case, but he was close to what the plan called for given waking hours.

Brown apparently was completely clueless about a plan developed with FEMA for exactly this kind of scenario. One of the reasons the evacuation from New Orleans didn’t look like Houston’s highways is that they hadn’t gotten Contraflow plans down very well after a debacle with Ivan. Without the sequencing the system doesn’t work.

The local officials other than Nagin on the Mandatory portion pretty much hit their timelines and got those out who would leave and had the means to leave in a remarkably efficient manor compared to Houston exactly because they called the evacuations as the did.

The exception is Nagin who made it pretty clear that people needed to get on the road as Contraflow opened up.

The resulting 80% that likely evacuated was the highest ever obtained by the City and to make matters worse for Brown’s point-of-view–he should have expected to have to move more people out by bus than he did.

He is utterly clueless to this day about his responsibilities and that of the federal government and about the local planning. This isn’t to say the local plan was adequate or that state and local officials didn’t make serious mistakes. I have pointed out Blanco’s mistakes with the National Guard, and I’ve now mentioned Nagin’s dithering on ordering a mandatory evacuation. All that said, the state and local authorities largely followed the plans developed between state, local and federal bodies. The Federal Government led by Brown denied the existence of those plans and apparently still doesn’t realize the grave errors made.

Does He Listen to Himself

Yeah, I can’t help myself

BROWN: Let me start out by addressing the premise of the question, which I don’t entirely agree with — that what could FEMA have done in terms of the evacuation? What could FEMA have done in terms of communications, law enforcement?

Those are not FEMA roles. FEMA doesn’t evacuate communities.

……………….

In terms of communications, one of the things that I didn’t mention in the litany of things that we pre-positioned is something called a MERS unit, our mobile emergency response system. Those are vehicles that are command and control units that have satellite hook- ups, telephone hook-ups, video hook-ups, enable us to do communications.

I pre-positioned those in all three states, so that we would have communications wherever we needed it. I eventually sent one of those command units — in fact, it’s one of the largest ones we have, called Red October — I eventually sent one of those into New Orleans for Mayor Nagin to use.

In retrospect, I wish I had done that four days earlier. Had I done it four days earlier, though, guess what? It probably wouldn’t have gotten there. So I am now second-guessing myself, and perhaps I should have pre-positioned it there before Katrina made landfall.

But again, that’s not the role of the federal government. That’s Mike Brown Monday morning quarterbacking, having seen everything that took place and trying to figure out, OK, now seeing everything that did not work in Louisiana, if I had known it beforehand, what could I have done?

I hate to break it to Mikey, but Communications probably is considered a federal issue given the problems with communications during 9-11.

The commission’s report will note that lawmakers, facing opposition from the broadcast industry, have not established a unified emergency communications system by dedicating a portion of the broadcast spectrum to medical and disaster responders.

As on Sept. 11, when malfunctioning radios contributed to deaths in the World Trade Center, public safety officials in New Orleans have reported widespread communications problems.

“The fact that Congress has chosen not to do something about this is a national scandal that has cost lives,” Kean said.

There was a big report by the folks on that commission. Maybe Brownie has heard of it.