ArchPundit

Illinois, From Misery
Subscribe
  • Home
  • Contact Information & Blog Bio
  • Advertising Liberally Blogs

It Only Takes 2 on JCAR

August 20, 2007 By: ArchPundit Category: G-Rod

The Blagojevich folks think they can get a few of the proposals around JCAR–I don’t buy that, but that’s for the courts to decide. However, on a couple issues everyone is in agreement that JCAR must sign off on the rule changes. For Blagojevich to get the rules changes he needs 5 votes in his favor–meaning out of six Democrats, 2 defecting Democrats can stop the rules. Unless there is a Republican vote to pick up, and that seems highly unlikely.
I’ll go out on a limb and say Fritchey is going to say no–and good for him.

House Republicans

Hassert Romeoville–strong Cross ally
Leitch–Peoria

Mulligan–Des Plaines

The only way Hassert switches is if Cross got behind some sort of deal, but that deal would have been made previously.  Not now.  Mulligan is slightly vulnerable as she is in the Northwest suburbs and in theory it could be an issue against her assuming she’s challenged by a Democrat this cycle.  The problem–running with Blagojevich in the Northwest suburbs would be an act of political suicide for any challenger. The one advantage good Democratic Lege candidates have is that they can run against the Governor since he’s essentially his own brand separate from the Democrats.

Senate Republicans
Burzynski–Sycamore

Hultgren–Wheaton

Rutherford–Pontiac

Uhhh…no.  Rutherford will vote against the rules with a smile. He might even break into talking about himself in the third person again as he did when Blagojevich campaigned against him on an early budget vote in Pontiac.  The others would have no rational electoral reason to defect from Watson.

Senate Democrats

Crotty–Oak Forest

Clayborne–East Saint Louis

Silverstein–Chicago

I’d imagine Crotty and Silverstein go with Emil on this.  Clayborne may pull out the institutionalist card and vote against the rules if he’s offended by the method.

House Democrats

Fritchey–Chicago  Uh…no.
Holbrook–Belleville
Miller–Dolton

Miller expresses reservations in the Post-Dispatch.  He doesn’t have any real threats so backing Madigan with a no would not be a problem for him.

Holbrook made his play blocking a budget bill at the end of May with other downstate Members to argue for electric rate relief first.  The only other thing I know about him is he has a decent environmental record.  Unless he is especially close with Jay Hoffman I wouldn’t see him backing the new rules.

Meaning the Governor has to sweep the Democratic Senators and take two House members or Mulligan.  The Governor will have no electoral power over those he’s trying to persuade.  Fritchey and him already don’t get along.  Clayborne, Miller, and Holbrook are all relatively safe seats.  Mulligan is a House Republican and only Madigan has anything to do with any decision to target her or not.

I don’t see how he gets five votes in his favor.  Six are guaranteed against him.  Of the other six, only two have to be against the rules and one is already signaling that is his attention and another is a Republican.

5 Responses to “ It Only Takes 2 on JCAR ”

  1. # 1 Rich Miller Says:
    August 21st, 2007 at

    No way does Mulligan vote for the new rules. The big questions are Holbrook and Crotty. Holbrook is tied with Hoffman, but goes both ways. Crotty is tied with Jones, of course, but switched to opposition on the guv’s health insurance bill.

  2. # 2 ArchPundit Says:
    August 21st, 2007 at

    What about Miller then? If he’s a no, that’s the ballgame. Six Rs, Fritchey and him.

  3. # 3 Rich Miller Says:
    August 21st, 2007 at

    Rod undercut Miller by lobbying against 750. And as I noted on my blog, Miller and Fritchey are very close.

  4. # 4 Rich Miller Says:
    August 21st, 2007 at

    But the question really isn’t what JCAR will do. The question is how they try to get around JCAR.

  5. # 5 ArchPundit Says:
    August 21st, 2007 at

    I think the administration thinks JCAR is an open question–I think they are wrong.

    That said, the only thing that happens then is a court case. And I cannot imagine circumstances in which the administration wins. The IL Lege isn’t full of poodles like Congress.

← Zorn’s Four Year Anniversary
Darin LaHood: 2008 Version of Sam Ewing →

  • blog advertising is good for you
  • Places To Find Me

    • Illinois Reason
    • Prairie State Blue
    • Daily Kos – ArchPundit
    • Show Me Progress
    • Illinoize
    • The Vital Voice
  • Illinois Blogs

    • Austin Mayor
    • Bridget in the Sixth
    • Progress Illinois
    • John Fritchey’s Open House
    • Peoria Pundit
    • OneMan
    • IlliniPundit
    • DJWinfo
    • Ellen of the Tenth
    • The Inside Dope
    • The 11th Hour
    • Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights
    • Illinois Democratic Network
    • Illinois Sierra Club
    • Move On and Shut Up
    • Where There’s a Will…
    • NarciBlog
    • Proviso Probe
    • Speaking Liberally
    • Reverse Spin
    • Russ Stewart
    • WurfWhile
    • Illinois Campaign for Political Reform
    • Spontaneous Solutions
    • McHenry County Blog
    • Illinois EnviroBlog
    • CTA Tattler
    • Gapers Block
    • Public Affairs
  • Illinois Press

    • The Capitol Fax
    • Change of Subject
    • Lynn Sweet
    • Illinois Issues
    • Illinois Channel
    • Sweeny Report
    • The Chicagoist
    • The Swamp
    • Clout Street
    • Clout City
    • News Bites
    • WCPT-820 AM
  • Illinois Specific

    • Daily Kos – Illinois
    • Stateline – Illinois
    • State Action – Illinois
  • Non-Political Illinois

    • Chicago Uncommon
  • BlogFathers

    • Daily Kos
    • MyDD
  • Progressive Organizations

    • Think Progress
    • Blog for Our Future
    • AFL-CIO
    • Working Life
    • CREW
    • AFSCME
    • Drum Major Institute
  • Liberal Blogs

    • Eschaton
    • Balloon Juice
    • Lawyers, Guns, and Money
    • AmericaBlog
    • Booman Tribune
    • Crooks and Liars
    • Hullabaloo
    • Firedoglake
    • OpenLeft
    • Street Prophets
    • Oliver Willis
    • Jesus’ General
    • The Poorman
    • Sadly No!
    • Talking Points Memo
    • TPM Election Central
    • TPM MuckRaker
    • TPM Horse’s Mouth
    • Pandagon
    • Cogitamusblog
    • Informed Comment
    • Brad DeLong
    • Pam’s House Blend
    • Seeing the Forest
    • The Reality Based Community
    • Rude Pundit
    • TalkLeft
    • Whiskey Fire
    • Cliff Schecter
  • Liberal Press Blogs

    • Matt Yglesias
    • Kevin Drum
    • Tapped
    • Washington Monthly
    • Paul Krugman
    • The ITT List
    • Unclaimed Territory
    • Ezra Klein
    • Beat The Press
    • Altercation
    • The Intersection
    • David Corn
    • Campaign Matters
    • Brave New Films
    • Chris Hayes
    • James Wolcott
    • Rachel Maddow
    • Spark – Air America
    • The Young Turks
    • Huffington Post
  • Democratic Party

    • The Stakeholder-DCCC
    • The Gavel-Speaker Pelosi
    • Kicking Ass-DNC
    • NDNBlog
    • The Democratic Strategist
    • From the Roots–DSCC
  • Political Comment-Polling

    • Political Wire
    • Pollster
    • Craig Crawford
    • The Hotline On Call
    • Blogometer
    • Ground Game
    • Political Arithmetik
    • Campaigns & Elections
    • CQ Polltracker
  • State Politics

    • Off The Kuff
    • Burnt Orange Report
    • Minnesota Campaign Report
    • Fired Up!
    • State Action
    • Progressive States Network
    • Stateline
    • The Thicket
  • Entertainment

    • The Watcher-Mo Ryan
    • Turn It Up-Greg Kot
    • OrbitCast
  • Sports

    • Trust But Verify
    • Podium Cafe
    • Bleed Cubbie Blue
  • BlogFathers

    • Daily Kos
    • MyDD
  • Democratic Party

    • From the Roots–DSCC
    • Kicking Ass-DNC
    • NDNBlog
    • The Democratic Strategist
    • The Gavel-Speaker Pelosi
    • The Stakeholder-DCCC
  • Entertainment

    • OrbitCast
    • The Watcher-Mo Ryan
    • Turn It Up-Greg Kot
  • Illinois Blogs

    • Austin Mayor
    • Bridget in the Sixth
    • CTA Tattler
    • DJWinfo
    • Ellen of the Tenth
    • Gapers Block
    • IlliniPundit
    • Illinois Campaign for Political Reform
    • Illinois Coalition for Immigrant and Refugee Rights
    • Illinois Democratic Network
    • Illinois EnviroBlog
    • Illinois Sierra Club
    • John Fritchey’s Open House
    • McHenry County Blog
    • Move On and Shut Up
    • NarciBlog
    • OneMan
    • Peoria Pundit
    • Progress Illinois
    • Proviso Probe
    • Public Affairs
    • Reverse Spin
    • Russ Stewart
    • Speaking Liberally
    • Spontaneous Solutions
    • The 11th Hour
    • The Inside Dope
    • Where There’s a Will…
    • WurfWhile
  • Illinois Press

    • Change of Subject
    • Clout City
    • Clout Street
    • Illinois Channel
    • Illinois Issues
    • Lynn Sweet
    • News Bites
    • Sweeny Report
    • The Capitol Fax
    • The Chicagoist
    • The Swamp
    • WCPT-820 AM
  • Illinois Specific

    • Daily Kos – Illinois
    • State Action – Illinois
    • Stateline – Illinois
  • Liberal Blogs

    • AmericaBlog
    • Balloon Juice
    • Booman Tribune
    • Brad DeLong
    • Cliff Schecter
    • Cogitamusblog
    • Crooks and Liars
    • Eschaton
    • Firedoglake
    • Hullabaloo
    • Informed Comment
    • Jesus’ General
    • Lawyers, Guns, and Money
    • Oliver Willis
    • OpenLeft
    • Pam’s House Blend
    • Pandagon
    • Rude Pundit
    • Sadly No!
    • Seeing the Forest
    • Street Prophets
    • Talking Points Memo
    • TalkLeft
    • The Poorman
    • The Reality Based Community
    • TPM Election Central
    • TPM Horse’s Mouth
    • TPM MuckRaker
    • Whiskey Fire
  • Liberal Press Blogs

    • Altercation
    • Beat The Press
    • Brave New Films
    • Campaign Matters
    • Chris Hayes
    • David Corn
    • Ezra Klein
    • Huffington Post
    • James Wolcott
    • Kevin Drum
    • Matt Yglesias
    • Paul Krugman
    • Rachel Maddow
    • Spark – Air America
    • Tapped
    • The Intersection
    • The ITT List
    • The Young Turks
    • Unclaimed Territory
    • Washington Monthly
  • Non-Political Illinois

    • Chicago Uncommon
  • Places To Find Me

    • Daily Kos – ArchPundit
    • Illinois Reason
    • Illinoize
    • Prairie State Blue
    • Show Me Progress
    • The Vital Voice
  • Political Comment-Polling

    • Blogometer
    • Campaigns & Elections
    • CQ Polltracker
    • Craig Crawford
    • Ground Game
    • Political Arithmetik
    • Political Wire
    • Pollster
    • The Hotline On Call
  • Progressive Organizations

    • AFL-CIO
    • AFSCME
    • Blog for Our Future
    • CREW
    • Drum Major Institute
    • Think Progress
    • Working Life
  • Sports

    • Bleed Cubbie Blue
    • Podium Cafe
    • Trust But Verify
  • State Politics

    • Burnt Orange Report
    • Fired Up!
    • Minnesota Campaign Report
    • Off The Kuff
    • Progressive States Network
    • State Action
    • Stateline
    • The Thicket

  • blog advertising is good for you

  • blog advertising is good for you
  • Archives



ArchPundit © 2007 All Rights Reserved. Using WordPress 3.3.1 Engine
Entries and Comments.

Prosumer 1.4 made by Nurudin Jauhari